SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge on Wednesday refused to dismiss a legal challenge to Proposition 8, concluding that the ongoing courtroom battle over California's voter-approved ban on gay marriage must be resolved in a full-blown trial.
After two hours of legal sparring, Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker rejected the arguments of Prop. 8 supporters, who maintained that U.S. Supreme Court precedent and a lack of proof of constitutional violations should sidetrack a lawsuit designed to overturn the ballot measure. Instead, Walker, sensing the challenge to Prop. 8 ultimately could wind up before the Supreme Court, wants a trial to develop a full factual record, including forcing Prop. 8 supporters to justify the reasons behind a state ban on allowing gay couples to wed.
One by one, the judge shot down the legal reasons Prop. 8 lawyers presented to resolve the case now and allow the same-sex marriage ban to remain in force. In particular, the judge seemed particularly unpersuaded by Prop. 8 attorney Charles Cooper's chief argument for a state law confining marriage to heterosexual couples — that the state has an interest in protecting "traditional" marriage because of its importance to procreation in society.
"Procreation doesn't require marriage," Walker noted, citing statistics showing that a large percentage of children are born out of wedlock. The judge's decision sets the stage for a January trial. Read the rest of the story here.
Clergy and lay leaders from a diversity of religious traditions are uniting in California Faith for Equality, a statewide network of congregations and people of faith committed to equality.
The California Faith for Equality coalition helps faith leaders and communities to become effectively engaged in the struggle for equality, while also helping secular LGBT leadership connect with these faith communities.
The California Faith for Equality News Blog is the place to come for up to date information and press releases regarding the struggle for marriage equality in California.